Know Your Neighbours: Paddling to Shipwrecks

February-March 2005

This is an article from WaveLength Magazine, available in print in North America and globally on the web.
To download a pdf copy of the magazine click here: > DOWNLOAD

by Bryan Nichols

There is something deeply disturbing about shipwrecks. No matter what size your boat is, a one way trip to Davy Jones’s Locker can still lurk in your mind every time the wind whips up. Once below the waves, ships become wrecks—rusting skeletons of their once beautiful selves, and watery cemeteries for any unfortunate souls who went down with them. Shipwrecks prickle our fascination with the mystery and power of the ocean. Many have remarkable histories, and all are a window into the past—the lifestyles of their passengers and crew frozen in time and then gradually lost to rust and encrusting marine life.

Divers are drawn to the shallower wrecks, able to explore what most people can only imagine. Wreck diving is so popular that old ships are now scuttled specifically for divers (“artificial reefs”). But what about kayakers? Can you experience a real shipwreck with paddle in hand? Strangely enough, many shipwreck sites are quite safe from a kayak—rocks and reefs that might hunger for your yacht are a playground for kayaks if the weather is calm.

WHAT THE TIDES REVEAL

In more protected areas, falling tides may uncover ships that ran aground, drifted in or were towed to shallow water. On exposed coasts, such shallow wrecks are soon battered to bits, but in calm areas you’ll be able to paddle right up to the remains of ships that met an inglorious or unlucky end. Some of the best examples are the breakwaters at Royston (see below and book review), Kelsey Bay and Powell River—some truly interesting ships were towed to these spots as hulks to protect log booming areas. However, there are beached wrecks scattered all along the coast, so you never know what you’ll come across. Though easiest to see, intertidal wrecks often met anticlimactic ends.

WHAT LIES BENEATH

Below the waves it’s different. Heroism. Tragedy. Cruel fate or miraculous survival. Even if you can’t actually see the rusting remains from a kayak, paddling to a spot where you know a ship met a dramatic end is an experience that can provoke a host of emotions, or at least satisfy an acute interest in history. With some research or a knowledgeable companion, visiting a shipwreck site can be a unique paddling experience.

Before visiting any wreck site, it’s worth knowing why a boat far bigger than yours went down there. Was it because of a fire on board? Fine, few of us kayakers worry about losing our craft to fire on the water. But perhaps it was because the weather in that area can turn nasty with lightning speed, or maybe the wind against current creates a sea unruly enough to founder a freighter. If so, you’d best be very aware of waves, winds and currents before you attempt a visit

.The West Coast Trail is a good example—it was built to speed aid to shipwreck victims, and there are plenty of wrecks just offshore in shallow water. But that stretch of coastline is exposed to the full fury of the Pacific, and hidey holes are few and far between if things get windy. Shallow wrecks have been smashed to smithereens by storms, and kayakers are not advised to go looking for them.

WHY SO MANY WRECKS?

A quick glance at a shipwreck chart (see Wreck References) makes you wonder— why are there so many? It’s a reminder that the ocean, even in protected areas like the Strait of Georgia, can be unforgiving at times—and those times are usually storms. It’s also a reminder that the lifejackets, fire drills and rescue procedures we often ignore or take for granted when we’re passengers, are there for a reason.

Things were different just a hundred years ago. It’s difficult for modern travelers to comprehend the steamship era— along a coast without highways, airports or a government ferry service, private companies and their steamships were vital links. Unfortunately, thanks to an inspection system that was inadequate and arguably even corrupt, travel by ship was more dangerous than it needed to be. The most horrifying tales of shipwrecks come from this era, tragedies like the Princess Sophia or Valencia. Read some of the books or websites in the reference list for stories that will provoke tears, fears and inspiration. Then head out for a visit with your hands on the paddle, one eye on the weather and your thoughts below the waves.

© Marine scientist Bryan Nichols encourages all boaters to learn about, and from, the Northwest’s wrecks.

Review:

The Ghost Ships of Royston

Rick James

Underwater Archaeological Society of BC, 2004

www.uasbc.com

$13 Cdn, 60 pp, b/w photographs

A fascinating book for boaters, travelers and especially kayakers, as old ships from all over the world ended up in shallow water on the east side of Vancouver Island. They were towed into place as a breakwater just south of Courtenay, and kayaks are a great way to check them out. Driving past on the highway you’d never know what lies there—a stop at the nearby park might reveal some rusting old hulls along a breakwater. But with a kayak, this book and a calm day, you can soak up some serious coastal history, bittersweet as it might seem. Several of the hulks you’ll see have such interesting pasts it seems like they should be in museums rather than being beaten into the mud by each winter storm.

The report is well referenced and provides enough information and old pictures of the ships to pique interest. From huge, three masted sailing ships to World War II frigates, this is an eclectic graveyard. There is a helpful archaeological survey map from 2003 showing what lies where, and some instructions on visiting the site. Order a copy from the UASBC website before an up island visit—it’s a very worthwhile stop.

WRECK REFERENCES

Underwater Archaeological Society of BC

www.uasbc.com

Graveyard of the Pacific Virtual Museum

www.pacificshipwrecks.ca

Shipwrecks of British Columbia

Fred Rogers (1973), Douglas & McIntyre

ISBN 0-88894-434-9

Melodramatic but interesting; good chart; best reference for finding wrecks.

See also Fred Roger’s More Shipwrecks of BC

ISBN 1-55054-020-3, 1992, $14.95 Cdn

Two recent books which could be better structured, but which have great tales:

Great Shipwrecks of the Pacific Coast

Robert C. Belyk, Wiley, 2001

ISBN 0-471-38420-8, $38.95 Cdn

The Unforgiving Coast

David H. Grover, Oregon State University

Press, 2002. ISBN 0-87071-541-0 $19.95 US.

 

British Columbia Shipwrecks

WRONG WAY TO DISCOVER REEFS

In 1930, the charts didn’t show the rock in the middle of one of the channels in the Broken Group. The H.M.S. Thiepval found it the hard way—after running aground, the crew got off but the ship didn’t. Fatally gouged, it slid and sunk sideways. Paddlers can easily visit the reef from popular campsites nearby. In summer the kelp draws your eyes down into the green water where the ship still lies.

NOT JUST IN THE OLDEN DAYS

On a reef outside of Effingham Island in the Broken Group lies the massive freighter the Vanleen. It ran hard aground in 1972 with 300 automobiles aboard. After being partially salvaged, the forward third was pounded to bits while most of the ship slid backwards into deeper water. It’s a dark and exciting wreck to visit as a diver, though the remaining cars have mostly rusted away. If the weather is good, the site is fascinating to visit in a kayak, with its nearby sea stacks and thick kelp beds.

HUNGRY PORLIER PASS

Lying between Galiano and Valdez Islands, Porlier Pass is an interesting place—wide and open to winds, but relatively shallow, which means tidal currents move erratically. Add some rocky reefs right near the middle and you’ve got a boat-hungry spot, and boats still do founder on those rocks. Virago reef holds the bones of the Point Grey, a steam tug that got stuck there in 1949, eventually rolling off and sinking in the 1960s. The Del Norte ran into Canoe Islet, just around the corner, in 1868. An interesting historic wreck, she was fitted with a rare boiler that powered a wheel on the side. Floating above in a kayak, it’s difficult to imagine a time when a sixty meter, steam-powered side wheeler moved through the Gulf Islands.

THE PANTHER MAKES A POINT

Wallace Island, near Saltspring, is a great spot for kayaking. A provincial marine park, there are camping spots, hiking trails and at the far south end, the shallow and treacherous point where the H.M.S. Panther ran aground way back in 1874. Though everyone got off safely, the ship lay undiscovered for nearly a century. Paddling past on a calm summer day, it’s worth contemplating what the spot would be like during a ship-eating storm. And if you’re mothership kayaking, beware, there are a lot of other rocks and reefs near Wallace Island.

THE LIGHTHOUSE COULDN’T SAVE HER

At the southern tip of Denman Island sits Chrome Island, with its historic (1891) lighthouse. Just offshore lies the remains of the S.S. Alpha, a large steamship that was wrecked on the rocks during a winter storm in 1900. Over a century of southeast gales have battered and scattered the Alpha—her bones are only five or six meters below as you drift past.

ROYSTON BREAKWATER

Paddling the breakwater at Royston is a strange experience—the falling tide could reveal the remains of over a dozen ships, including old whaling boats, schooners, navy frigates and tugs. The most interesting is probably the Melanope, a 79-meter, three-masted sailing ship built in 1876. Pick a calm day to visit and stay clear of the booming grounds on the inside.

MIAMI ROCK

Miami Rock, an innocent looking islet lying between Vancouver Island and the north end of Thetis Island, has reefs with a taste for ships. In 1900 the ship Miami struck the north side (towards the red marker), sinking in relatively shallow water. Eleven years later, the Robert Kerr ended up on the reef to the southeast, never to leave. Kayakers can cruise the islet and reef and both wrecks are divable, though currents and low visibility often make them difficult to visit.

GHOST LIFEBOAT

The harrowing tale of the Valencia is depressingly thin on heroics or luck. Trapped just offshore, most of the men and all of the women and children died as the waves took two agonizing days to pound the ship to pieces. Though the wreck lies along the exposed West Coast Trail (indeed, it’s one of the main reasons for the trail), paddlers who are exploring the intriguing sea caves of Barkley Sound might consider the Valencia. In 1933, 27 years after the Pacific took the liner and about 130 passengers, lifeboat #5 was found floating in the Sound. How that is possible remains a mystery, but the rumors of a boat full of skeletons trapped deep in a sea cave can haunt you.

EELS & COPPER ORE

Port Hardy paddlers might swing by Crocker Rock, the final resting place of the Themis, which was swept ashore during a nasty gale in 1906. Open to a swell, this is a place that requires care and calm weather to visit. Below, you will see copper ore and the shattered bow, with the skeletal stern a bit deeper. The site is renowned among divers because the wreck makes a great home for wolf eels. Believe it or not, a shipwreck infested with these long, fearsome looking fish actually makes for a very interesting and popular dive.

MYSTERY IN THE NUCHATLITZ

Paddlers cruising through the remote Nuchatlitz islands often come across a large wreck on one of the beaches. The wild location and surreal, twisting remains of metal and wood make for an interesting experience. I’ve heard it’s either the Sophie Christensen (1951) or the Treis Ierarcha (1969), but whatever it was, at low tide the wreckage now seems more like the beached skeleton of a huge beast than a freighter or barge.

A juvenile rockfish hides in the rusting remains of the Vanleen.
Twisted metal on a beach in the Nuchatlitz area.

© 2005. Text and photos by Bryan Nichols. No reproduction without permission.